Homepage Redesign for Paula's Choice

Homepage Redesign for Paula's Choice

Homepage Redesign for Paula's Choice

Category:

Product Design · UX/UI

Created For:

Paula’s Choice

As the only UX Designer at Paula’s Choice Europe (now part of Unilever Prestige), I led a full redesign of our e-commerce homepage. The previous version, though functional, felt outdated and disjointed. With evolving business needs and increased focus on brand storytelling and discoverability, our team initiated a comprehensive revamp to modernize the page without compromising conversion.

The Challenge


Fragmented layout: Content blocks were added ad hoc over time, creating inconsistency

Limited discoverability: Key tools like the skin analyzer and quick category access were hidden or hard to find

Legacy structure: Updating without hurting the conversion rate required data-informed caution

Goals & Success Metrics


We defined our objectives early on:

  • Increase discoverability of key content like the product discovery tool

  • Refresh outdated aesthetics to better reflect brand identity

  • Improve campaign flexibility for marketing teams

  • Lay a foundation for scalable, block-based architecture across Salesforce Commerce Cloud

  • Enhance user experience without negatively impacting conversion rate


Success would be measured by:

  • A/B test performance (conversion, CTR)

  • Scroll depth and click maps from Hotjar

  • Stakeholder satisfaction and usage flexibility

Research & Insights


We used a combination of Hotjar, Google Analytics, and A/B testing data to uncover how users interacted with the homepage.

Key insights included:

  • Users heavily interacted with campaign blocks and discovery tools but often missed them due to poor visibility.

  • Scroll behavior showed drop-off around the third block, signaling a need for stronger visual rhythm.

  • Mobile performance lagged slightly in engagement, especially when discovery tools were buried below the fold.


Design Process


We began with quick ideation sessions using methods like Crazy 8s to explore alternative structures and modular ideas. Once aligned, I created wireframes and then transitioned into high-fidelity design, always keeping modularity in mind for implementation on Salesforce.

The homepage was broken down into functional blocks such as:

  • Hero + Campaign Banner

  • Quick Access Carousel

  • Product Discovery Tool

  • Featured Categories & Educational Content

  • Brand Story & Testimonials


Each block was validated with stakeholders and prioritized for staged rollout.

Stakeholder Collaboration


Since the homepage plays a strategic role across multiple departments, I actively gathered input from:

  • Marketing: campaign needs and banner placement

  • Product/Content team: search, quiz tools, category promotion

  • Customer Care: accessibility, pain points, user feedback


We held structured reviews and documented requirements to ensure modular flexibility while still honoring our UX principles.

Implementation & QA


We worked with a Salesforce-based development team, and I coordinated with them directly to hand off specs, document responsive behavior, and monitor releases.

Each block was delivered and deployed in phases. I created detailed documentation per block, including responsiveness guidelines, interaction notes, and fallback behaviors.

Before each go-live, I conducted QA on staging environments and worked closely with the devs to ensure visual and functional consistency.


A/B Test Results


Hypothesis

If we redesign the homepage to reduce promotional clutter and emphasize brand storytelling, users will experience the brand more meaningfully without negatively affecting CVR, AOV, or RPU.


Metric

Control

New Checkout

Difference

CVR

-*

-*

+1.3% (Not significant)

AOV

-*

-*

–1.4% (Not significant)

RPU

-*

-*

+1.6% to +6.4% depending on country (Not significant)


Hypothesis directionally supported: Revenue metrics stable or slightly improved in multiple markets
📉 CVR down in some regions (e.g. NL: –4.7%) but up in others (UK: +2%) — not statistically significant
📈 AOV generally improved on desktop (+3.5%), dipped slightly on mobile
🔍 Product engagement behavior changed — more clicks on filters, fewer on promo/video blocks


*Exact figures cannot be disclosed due to company confidentiality.

Outcome & Learnings

  • Desktop performance improved significantly over mobile, especially in AOV

  • Revenue remained stable or improved in all key markets (Germany, France, UK, NL)

  • Click behavior redistributed across the page, with more engagement on navigation filters and fewer on sliders or promo banners

  • Brand storytelling sections saw greater visibility, creating a more balanced visual hierarchy

  • No negative impact on revenue per user, supporting brand-forward design without sales compromise

⚠️ Room for improvement

  • Hero video button saw 33% fewer clicks, even with the same content

  • Featured articles with video/image had lower than expected CTR, despite strong placement

  • Further mobile optimization needed — mobile AOV dropped slightly, especially on listing pages

  • New design requires additional user testing to understand perception gaps and layout behavior

Reflection


This project was more than just a visual refresh — it was an opportunity to rethink how our homepage could tell the Paula’s Choice story, guide users with purpose, and remain performant.

I’m especially proud of how we balanced cross-team needs while keeping UX at the center, and how we built a modular system that could evolve with the brand.

If given more time, I would have loved to test personalization modules or audience-segmented hero banners.

Let’s create thoughtful things. Thanks for scrolling all the way down — you're my kind of person.

Let’s create thoughtful things. Thanks for scrolling all the way down — you're my kind of person.

Let’s create thoughtful things. Thanks for scrolling all the way down — you're my kind of person.