Checkout Redesign for Paula’s Choice

Checkout Redesign for Paula’s Choice

Checkout Redesign for Paula’s Choice

Category:

UX Design, E-Commerce

Created For:

Paula’s Choice

Background


As part of our shift toward a headless e-commerce architecture, we faced multiple urgent pressures to redesign our checkout experience:

  • Technical trigger: Adyen stopped supporting our legacy Salesforce integration. We migrated to a composable setup using Contentstack as CMS.

  • UX trigger: The legacy checkout was overly long, cluttered, and fragmented across our 7 regional websites, each with slightly different field needs. For example:

    • "Packstation" fields were displayed to all countries, even those not using the service.

    • Mandatory house number or company info fields appeared in markets where they weren’t needed.

    • The form appeared bloated and irrelevant, leading to errors and user drop-offs.

The redesign was not just about UI; it was a strategic infrastructure move, decoupling checkout from Salesforce to support long-term scalability.

Goal


Create a streamlined, modern one-pager checkout that:

  • Reduces friction and confusion

  • Collapses irrelevant sections with progressive disclosure (folded steps)

  • Allows easy in-place editing

  • Supports local logic (e.g. country-specific field requirements)

  • Works seamlessly with modern payment methods and backend integrations

Research & Methodology


Our redesign was backed by layered research:

  • Quantitative:

    • 5+ years of A/B test history on legacy checkout

    • Google Analytics & revenue tracking for CVR, AOV, RPU

    • Session-based behavioral analysis via Hotjar (~100 recordings/day during test phase)

  • Qualitative:

    • Usability testing with real users across key markets

    • Stakeholder interviews from e-commerce, data, and customer support teams

    • Competitive benchmarking (e.g. how brands like Zalando or Sephora handle one-pager checkouts)

My Role


I led the UX Design for this high-impact project, owning:

  • Flow logic and UX strategy

  • Field-level logic mapping across 7 country-specific checkouts

  • Wireframes → high-fidelity mockups (Figma)

  • Design QA & collaboration with frontend/backend devs

  • Design decisions around components like:

    • Payment method selection

    • Gift card handling (moved from "payment" to "promo" for better UX & tech feasibility)

    • Inline validation + visual summary

  • Synthesizing daily insights from Hotjar, collaborating closely with e-commerce analyst

Collaboration was mainly with:
E-commerce team · Dev & IT · Data team (no marketing/legal dependencies in this phase)

Hypothesis

If we redesign the checkout with a composable architecture, we will not observe significant drops in CVR, AOV, or RPU — because the new UX is optimized for a smoother and clearer experience.

A/B Test Results

Metric

Control

New Checkout

Difference

CVR

94.7%

94.4%

-0.3% (Not significant)

AOV

-*

-*

-0.4% (Not significant)

RPU

-*

-*

-0.7% (Not significant)


Hypothesis confirmed: No significant revenue drop
📉 Add-to-cart dropped on listing pages (-xx%*)
📈 But increased on PDP (+xx%*) → Indicates stronger product purchase intent

*Exact figures cannot be disclosed due to company confidentiality.

Outcome & Learnings

  • Revenue metrics remained stable across core markets

  • Checkout became visually and functionally cleaner, localized, and less error-prone

  • Removed the need for users to navigate multiple steps and external loading pages

  • Gift card UX simplified, backend constraints reduced

⚠️ Room for improvement

  • UK market showed CVR dip tied to account creation friction — now prioritized for next iteration

  • Some payment methods temporarily malfunctioned due to integration issues — resolved via Hotjar monitoring

Final Thoughts


This project proved the value of thoughtful UX grounded in both behavioral and technical research. It was not just a visual refresh — it was a structural transformation that made our checkout faster, smarter, and future-ready.

Let’s create thoughtful things. Thanks for scrolling all the way down — you're my kind of person.

Let’s create thoughtful things. Thanks for scrolling all the way down — you're my kind of person.

Let’s create thoughtful things. Thanks for scrolling all the way down — you're my kind of person.